When did plastic plants become acceptable?

Plants are important.  Really, really important.  They play important roles in society and in the nature that supports our societies: plants feed us; they are a source of many pharmaceuticals; they produce oxygen and store up carbon dioxide; they can remove pollutants from city atmospheres; and they are the foundation for much of the world’s ecological functioning.  In addition they inspire poets, artists, musicians, and have huge cultural significance, as well as bringing beauty and biodiversity to even the most urban of environments. Plants positively add to our quality of life, and make us happy, whether we are aware of it or not.

OK, there’s a bit of personal bias going on here: I’ve always loved studying and growing plants, they are a huge part of my life.  But the basic facts of what I laid out in that opening paragraph are correct: plants matter.  So I find it troubling that there seems to be a recent trend in using artificial (mainly plastic) plants indoors and in outside “gardens”.  When did this happen?  When did plastic plants become acceptable?

It first struck me that there had been a recent shift in how we view plastic plants back in the summer when I visited the newly refurbished main restaurant at the university’s Park Campus.  The refurb was very nicely done and there’s a big display about how much of the university’s waste we are recycling, and there’s lots of greenery about the place – except that most of it is plastic.

Then in November we visited my son Patrick in Lancaster.  We stayed a night in a nice hotel in the city centre, in a room that led out into a private courtyard – full of plastic plants.  There was a plastic lawn, a plastic palm, even plastic ivy.  Ivy!  One of the easiest plants in the world to grow – why would you need to make it out of plastic?!  It makes itself perfectly well which you can see if you peep over the wall at the back of the courtyard:

lancaster-courtyard-20161113_101336

Then the following week I was in London at the Wellcome Trust to take part in a project review panel.  The Wellcome’s building near Euston Station is wonderful, really striking on the inside, full of light and life.  I was initially please to see an avenue of fig trees in large containers arrayed along the centre of the main concourse:

wellcome-trust-20161115_123554

But when I looked closely I realised that although the trunks and branches were real, these were not living plants: the leaves are artificial, made from wire and synthetic material.  So someone has gone to the trouble of growing real fig trees only to dismember them and festoon them with faux foliage.  Please, no one tell Mike Shanahan!

I’m really surprised at the Wellcome Trust, an organisation I have a lot of respect for;  we know that real plants have a positive effect on psychology and health, though I very much doubt that the same can be said for artificial ones.  In their defence the Wellcome Trust building does have some real plants scattered about the place, but they missed a huge opportunity in not using real figs here.  Even that cathedral to capitalism that is the Milton Keynes shopping centre uses real plants in most of its displays, including some lovely tree ferns:

mk-tree-fern-20161204_162151

And splendid palms:

mk-palm-20161204_150755

Finally, insult was added to injury as we entered the New Year.  As I mentioned in my Spiral Sunday post a couple of weeks ago, we bought a wreath as a Christmas decoration and I took it apart to compost and recycle at the start of the year.  What I hadn’t noticed when we bought it was that half of the holly berries were plastic:

wreath-20170107_130333

This was hugely ironic given our recent study of how insects boost the value of holly by pollinating the female flowers that produce the berries!

All of this is more than just snobbery on my part.  Yes, you can argue that plastic plants are a bit naff and can never take the place of the “real” thing.  But my main concern here is an environmental one: plastic plants require resources (usually oil-based polymers and energy) to make.  And I doubt very much whether they are recycled very often.  Yes, real plants also cost resources to grow (though that can be minimised depending on how they are grown).  But they also provide a range of benefits and, at the end of their life, they can be composted.  Not something I can do with my plastic holly berries.  Not only that, but I suspect that most (all?) of the plastic plants that are sold are manufactured in the Far East.  Using British- or Europe-grown real plants would cut down on the carbon-miles required and support more local horticultural industries.

Early in 2017 Andrew Lucas at Swansea University, on Twitter, described what he thought was the most depressing tweet of 2017 so far:  “Transform your garden today: buy Artificial Grass from ExpressGrass. Cut to your size for easy DIY installation”.

Agreed, hugely depressing, but we can do something about it: stop buying fake plants.  Perhaps we need a Campaign for Real Plants?  Its theme tune could be Radiohead’s Fake Plastic Trees:

Her green plastic watering can
For her fake Chinese rubber plant
In the fake plastic earth
That she bought from a rubber man
In a town full of rubber plans
To get rid of itself…..

……It wears me out

Advertisements

15 Comments

Filed under Biodiversity, Biodiversity and culture, Ecosystem services, Gardens, Personal biodiversity, Pollination, University of Northampton, Urban biodiversity

15 responses to “When did plastic plants become acceptable?

  1. Good rant. Part of the problem is that artificial plants are now so realistic looking. People find them perfectly acceptable aesthetically, whereas in the past they were distinctly naff. Boo to the tree fern though — they are all taken from the wild, and even when legally done under licence due to ‘development’ of their habitat, it is contentious.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I find all the fake plants disturbing too. I see more and more fake grass in London. People like it because it needs no maintenance and kids don’t get muddy. But it’s soulless and bad for birds, bees and other wildlife.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Murtagh's Meadow

    It all boils down to so called convenience. Hotels or other organisations just can’t be bothered with all the maintenance, watering etc that real plants need. But I agree with everything you say!

    Liked by 1 person

  4. I love the MK plants too. There were even sparrows in fig trees with ripe figs on last time I went. 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Can’t get over that plastic garden in Lancaster, even if you were only think aesthetically, it’s awful. Surprised at Wellcome too.

    Despite being a bit naff, I think plastic flowers can be useful; I would wager that having the same plastic flowers for a long time in a vase is less destructive that buying fresh cut flowers all the time. Even then though, there are ways and means to produce them sustainably!

    Liked by 1 person

  6. My daughter thinks we could get fake grass after seeing it at one of her friend’s (they have a concrete yard which is covered with AstroTurf).

    The fake ivy at Lancaster does look fake – or at least because it can be contrasted with the real stuff on the other side of the wall.

    Liked by 1 person

  7. Yes I too have noticed a) how good the fake flower people have got and b) how sad it is that whilst it is now recognised that greenery is good for people’s well-being that convenience dictates that fake plants are used in preference to real ones. It might be interesting to do a study on whether people feel better in the presence of real versus fake plant material

    Liked by 1 person

  8. Do you think it is connected to the ageing population? I must confess to having had to touch some over-perfect plants just to be certain. Amelia

    Liked by 1 person

  9. Alex Laws

    I had to top and prune a silver birch in my garden last year because the neighbour complained about it on two counts. Firstly, it was shading his garden. It was growing rather large for the space so fair enough, but he was concerned about getting a sun tan, not growing plants. Secondly (and this is the good bit) when he vacuumed his artificial lawn the catkins were blocking up his vacuum cleaner! On first hearing this from my tenant to whom the complaint was made, whilst inspecting the silver birch in question, I laughed so hard I nearly choked. Only then did I discover the neighbour was sunbathing on the other side of the fence and heard the whole conversation. Oops.

    Liked by 1 person

  10. My local Garden Centre (which is now more like a gift shop) stocks plastic flowers and decorations all year now. There’s something wrong with the world when this happens – whether in terms of biodiversity, sustainability or even spiritualty.

    Liked by 1 person

  11. Hi Admin,

    This blog have wonderful content, i liked that. you wrote a such a nice content about the Box hedge. Thank you so much to sharing that information.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s